Lighting

Mlazgar Owes $9.25 Million as Fourth Circuit Weighs Collection Stay

A Minnesota lighting agency is asking the Richmond-based appeals court to pause collection of a $10.7 million judgment while two motions and a separate Minneapolis trial play out.

Hana IshikawaNovember 15, 20265 min read2 views
A brass balance scale on a conference table, its heavier pan weighed down by a thick stack of legal briefs and a sealed exhibit folder.

A Minnesota lighting agency that lost a $10.7 million breach-of-contract verdict now owes roughly $9.25 million, and it is asking a federal appeals court in Richmond to delay collection while it challenges the judgment. The dispute has also pulled a 2020 Cooper Lighting slide deck onto the public docket.

On August 31, Judge Jacquelyn D. Austin entered judgment awarding Hubbell Lighting $10,724,878 on its breach of contract counterclaim. R.L. Mlazgar Associates won $1,478,848 under South Carolina's sales representative statute, half of it punitive. The offset leaves the agency owing about $9.25 million.

An automatic 30-day hold on collection expired October 1. Mlazgar asked Judge Austin in September to extend it and has received no ruling. On November 3 it took the request to the Fourth Circuit, asking that collection be blocked until February 18, 2027, and that it be allowed to file its balance sheet under seal.

Two arguments for more time

Mlazgar offers two reasons. Its fee petition, seeking $3,843,818, and a request for $319,616 in prejudgment interest remain pending in Greenville and could shrink the net figure. Separately, Mlazgar goes to trial in Minneapolis on January 19 against Focal Point, where its lawyers say a large recovery "could assist" the agency in posting security.

Hubbell Lighting's opposition dismissed Mlazgar's warnings about its finances as "ipse dixit," legal shorthand for an assertion offered without proof. It leaned on a 2010 South Carolina ruling that refused a stay despite the debtor's claimed inability to pay, warning that a judgment holder should not be "forced to fund an appeal on the unsupported hope" of later payment.

Exhibits describe a smaller book of business

Trial exhibits from August make that hope look thin, according to the filing. In 2019, the last full calendar year before the fallout, Mlazgar and Elan Lighting — the Wisconsin agency Mlazgar later acquired — represented Focal Point and its sister company Kenall. The two lines generated roughly $333,000 and $149,000 in commissions. In the same year, Mlazgar earned approximately $941,000 in commissions representing Hubbell Lighting.

Those figures describe a relationship about half the size of the one that produced the verdict. If a Minneapolis jury awarded the equivalent of one to three years of those commissions, the total would land between the mid six figures and the low seven figures — a fraction of what the agency owes Hubbell Lighting.

A rare request for summary reversal

Alongside the stay request, Mlazgar filed a motion for summary reversal, a procedure that lets an appeals court discard a judgment without full briefing when the issues are "manifestly unsubstantial." Courts typically use it when precedent has already settled a question. Mlazgar is seeking it after a nine-day jury trial and a $10.7 million verdict.

The agency argues that the exclusivity clause it breached is an unenforceable non-compete under South Carolina law, and that a separate contract provision bars Hubbell Lighting's lost-profit damages. Hubbell Lighting's response calls the motion "meritless and borders on frivolous," says the district court rejected the liability argument three times, and notes that Mlazgar cited no case from any circuit summarily reversing a jury verdict.

The Cooper deck

Hubbell Lighting filed the Cooper deck under seal in Greenville last month; in the Richmond appeals court it sits on the public docket. Sent by then-Cooper executive Shane Bickley under the subject line "Mlazgar Rollout," the October 9, 2020 presentation laid out a 30-day launch plan, including a step to "Execute plan to convert Hubbell stock positions at Mlazgar strongholds."

It also called for a "Market Blitz" aimed at the top 20 contractors, distributors and specifiers, emphasizing customers holding existing Hubbell Lighting projects, plus a promotion "to incentivize quick conversions from Hubbell." Hubbell Lighting uses the deck to rebut Mlazgar's claim that its breach did not cause the lost profits, writing that Mlazgar and Cooper "were plotting the very losses that HLI incurred even prior to the breach."

Mlazgar can reply before a three-judge panel takes up the stay. The panel could grant a temporary pause, deny it, or leave the matter to Judge Austin, who has had the September request on her desk for eight weeks. For lighting people, the larger question is what it now costs to walk away from a Minnesota rep.

Inside Lighting emailed Mlazgar's attorneys for comment on the afternoon of November 12 from two separate addresses. The firm's automated replies arrived overnight, but no comment came before publication.